Funny how much better some bosses get


PRACTICAL PERSPECTIVES

ISSUE 28 | BEST BOSS NEVER

On the leaders we remember, and the ones we work for now.

Funny how much better some bosses get once you stop working for them.

Take the boss who could make a decision in ten minutes.

You admired that about them. Until they made a decision without consulting you, dismissed a legitimate concern, or charged ahead before anyone could point out what might go wrong.

Then you get a new boss.

This one wants everyone’s opinion. Every decision requires another conversation, another meeting, another opportunity for someone to weigh in.

And suddenly, you’re reminiscing about how decisive your former boss was.

Funny. You used to call that impulsive.

I hear both sides of this in coaching conversations.

Executives frustrated by bosses who make decisions without enough input. And executives equally frustrated by bosses who can’t make a decision without consulting half the company.

Each is longing for something the other can’t stand.

And I wonder how much our opinion of a leader depends on who comes next.

My own highlight reel

I can think of a leader I worked for whom I remember with tremendous admiration.

They were thoughtful, considered different perspectives, and took seriously how their decisions would affect people.

There was a lot to admire.

There was also plenty that frustrated me.

Difficult conversations sometimes took too long to happen. Decisions that needed to be made could get caught up in trying to bring everyone along.

Then I worked for someone whose approach was quite different.

And I found myself appreciating the first leader even more.

What I’d conveniently forgotten was how impatient I’d sometimes been for a decision. How frustrated I’d been when a difficult conversation was put off yet again.

Those things hadn’t stopped being true.

They’d just stopped being part of the story I told about that leader.

The problem with the highlight reel

We don’t necessarily remember former bosses inaccurately. We remember them selectively.

The things we miss become more prominent. The things that used to irritate us fade.

Meanwhile, we’re experiencing our current leaders in full, complete with every frustrating habit and questionable decision.

It’s an unfair competition.

And it can make working for someone considerably more frustrating than it needs to be.

Because once you’ve decided your former boss handled something better, it’s awfully easy to notice every occasion when your current boss falls short.

You start anticipating the drawn-out decision. The unnecessary discussion. The approach you wouldn’t have chosen.

And you may be right about all of it.

But while you’re keeping track of everything they don’t do as well, what aren’t you noticing?

Perhaps your current boss is particularly good at something your previous one struggled with. Maybe they’re navigating challenges your former boss never faced. Or they have an approach you’ve never considered, much less learned from.

You can be right about what your current boss does poorly and still be missing what they do exceptionally well.

And that’s a shame. Because even if you never come to prefer their approach, there’s probably something worth learning from it.

Something to consider

Think about the best boss you’ve ever had.

What made them so good?

Now, if you’re being fair, what drove you crazy about them?

And finally, think about someone you’re working with today whose approach frustrates you.

What might they be exceptionally good at that your favorite boss never was?

You may still prefer your old boss.

But wouldn’t it be interesting to recognize what you’ll miss about this one before you stop working together?

Warmly,
Angela

P.S. We don’t just do this with people. We do it with entire organizations. I explored that tendency in my latest BioSpace article, Your Last Company Was Great. Stop Trying to Recreate It.​

600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

Practical Perspectives

Decisions, tradeoffs, and people dynamics—told from the inside.

Read more from Practical Perspectives
Practical Perspectives | Issue 25 | mind your business on yellow background

PRACTICAL PERSPECTIVES ISSUE 25 | MIND YOUR BUSINESS On promotions, functional loyalty, and thinking like an owner. One of the quickest ways I learned to distinguish a strong functional leader from a business leader was to watch what happened when they didn’t get what they wanted. As a CPO, I saw it all the time in promotion discussions. A leader would come in with a strong case. Their person had delivered. The scope had grown. They were already operating at the next level. The retention risk...

Practical Perspectives | Issue 24 | LOOKING BACK on yellow background

PRACTICAL PERSPECTIVES ISSUE 24 | LOOKING BACK On the decisions you don't recognize until you look back. I almost didn't go. I'd been invited into an executive women's leadership program. Several days. Residential. Fully away from work. My team had too much going on. I couldn't make the calendar math work in my head — several days away now, another session a few months later. So I said no. Then I sat with that answer. And changed my mind. Not because the timing got better. It didn't. I said...

Practical Perspectives | Issue 23 | THE POLITE TAX on yellow background

PRACTICAL PERSPECTIVES ISSUE 22 | THE POLITE TAX On niceness, candor, and the conversations that never happen. Hi Reader,Early in the pandemic, a photo from a Minnesota grocery store started circulating. I wish I had saved it, because it explained Minnesota better than anything I could write. The produce section had been picked over almost completely. Except for one apple.One head of lettuce.One zucchini. Apparently, even in a panic, nobody wanted to be the person who took the last one. I...