Your culture may be too nice


PRACTICAL PERSPECTIVES

ISSUE 22 | THE POLITE TAX

On niceness, candor, and the conversations that never happen.

Hi Reader,

Early in the pandemic, a photo from a Minnesota grocery store started circulating.

I wish I had saved it, because it explained Minnesota better than anything I could write.

The produce section had been picked over almost completely.

Except for one apple.
One head of lettuce.
One zucchini.

Apparently, even in a panic, nobody wanted to be the person who took the last one.

I grew up in Minnesota, where “nice” is less a personality trait and more a social operating system.

We don’t honk.
We don’t interrupt.
And we definitely don’t want to make anyone uncomfortable.

The older I get, the more I realize how often that instinct follows people into organizations.

Especially good ones.

That’s part of what makes this dynamic difficult to recognize.

When tension gets avoided in a toxic culture, it looks dysfunctional.

When tension gets avoided in a nice culture, it often looks collaborative.

Someone softens the feedback.
Someone changes the subject.
Someone says, “I think we’re actually saying the same thing.”

Nobody wants to be the person who takes the last zucchini.

Meanwhile, the real issue survives untouched.

That is the polite tax.

The problem isn't kindness.

The problem is when social comfort becomes more important than candor.

If every difficult conversation has to pass a comfort test before it can happen, people spend more energy making the message acceptable than making it useful.

Can we raise this without sounding negative?

Can we disagree without seeming unsupportive?
Can we say this in a way that nobody experiences as uncomfortable?

Eventually the concern gets raised.

But only after enough cushioning that nobody is entirely sure how serious it actually is.

You see it in decisions that keep getting revisited.
Projects everyone publicly supports but privately questions.
Cross-functional tensions renamed as “alignment work.”

Most organizational problems don't start with conflict.
They start with conversations that never happened.

Strong leadership cultures do not eliminate discomfort.

They stop treating disagreement as damage.

That requires leaders who can disagree without escalation.
Raise concerns without dramatics.
Ask harder questions without making the conversation feel unsafe.

Try this in your next leadership meeting

Notice the exact moment a group collectively moves away from tension.

The joke.
The over-explaining.
The sudden rush toward agreement.

Then calmly say:

“I think we just skipped past something important. Can we go back for a minute?”

Not aggressively.

Just directly enough that the real conversation happens.

Because the polite tax rarely shows up in the moment.

It shows up later.
In slower execution,
Weaker decisions,
And teams that look highly aligned right up until the moment they aren’t.

The test of a strong culture is not whether people are comfortable all the time.

It’s whether they trust each other enough to say what the work requires.

That is where niceness becomes something stronger.

Warmly,
Angela

P.S. I still may never take the last zucchini. But strong teams cannot afford to leave the hard conversation behind.

600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Practical Perspectives

Decisions, tradeoffs, and people dynamics—told from the inside.

Read more from Practical Perspectives
Practical Perspectives | Issue 22 | VERSION CONTROL on yellow background

PRACTICAL PERSPECTIVES ISSUE 22 | VERSION CONTROL On behavior, perception, and the cost of outdated stories. “You don’t know her like we do.” We were in a talent review session discussing up-and-coming leaders — who was ready for what, who needed more time, who should get the next big opportunity. One leader’s name came up. What people were saying didn’t match what I had seen. I found myself wondering: Are we talking about the same person? I didn’t say that out loud. But I did share a few...

Practical Perspectives | Issue 21 | IT TAKES TWO on yellow background

PRACTICAL PERSPECTIVES ISSUE 21 | IT TAKES TWO On changing the trajectory of a career. I've had a lot of great bosses in my career. People I respected. Learned from. Genuinely enjoyed working for. If I'm honest, I've been unusually lucky on that front. But if I ask a different question — not who was good, but who actually changed the trajectory of my career — the list gets very short. It was two.What set them apart was not that they made work easier. It was that they moved me further, faster...

Practical Perspectives | Issue 20 | depth perception on yellow background

PRACTICAL PERSPECTIVES ISSUE 20 | DEPTH PERCEPTION On what changes when the job gets bigger than your expertise. I got lucky early in my career. I just didn’t know how lucky at the time. My first role after McKinsey was an EVP position at a regional nonprofit. I was responsible for everything from programming and patient advocacy to IT and marketing. I had no deep expertise in any of those functions. That may sound like a strange setup. If you’re not the technical expert, what exactly is your...